progesterone molecule

Progesterone Research

Bringing you the message behind the science


Is natural progesterone cream a scam?

Research Papers

Ageing
Behavioural disorders
Blood lipids
Breast cancer
Candida
Cardio vascular disease
Diabetes
Dr Dalton
Endometrial cancer
Epilepsy
Hysterectomy
Leptins
Men and progesterone
Miscellaneous
Neuro protection
Ovarian cancer
Parasites
Post traumatic stress disorder
More resources

"Is natural progesterone cream a scam?"

Hello, I'm Jane Miller and I'm here to help you avoid being a victim and being scammed. I was a victim... three times over! I set up "Progesterone Research" specifically to bring you the facts.

Before we go any further... this is quite a long message and although its full of vitally useful information that I hope will benefit you directly if you want answers without the read just scroll to the bottom and do the 10 minute questionnaire.

The First time I found myself a victim...

For years I suffered from several illnesses with some pretty nasty symptoms. All were seemingly unrelated. Here are a few...

  • anxiety and panic attacks
  • severe depression
  • lack of self confidence
  • chronic fatigue
  • muscular weakness
  • mental confusion
  • clumsiness
  • cold hands and feet
  • dizziness
  • facial hair
  • short term memory loss
  • flaking nails
  • loss of libido
  • weight gain

Think that's a long list? Its not the half of it!

Second, I was a victim of a scam. Let me explain. My life was a wreck and the only thing that kept me going was the need for a solution to my seemingly endless and overwhelming health problems. I felt as if I was somehow "inventing" my own bad health because I kept asking myself "how is it possible that you can have so many apparently unconnected health problems?". I was often told "its all in your mind".

I felt like a fraud. Until I had my hormones tested.

I won't bore you with the years of struggle to just get through each day trying to appear as "normal" as possible to family and friends and at the same time trying to find solutions.

But, having my hormones tested opened a great window... and exposed me to a scam.

The hormone tests revealed that my progesterone levels were so low they were almost off the chart. I was excited as my hopes rose that these ultra low progesterone levels could prove the source of my problems.

As I discovered... progesterone is so fundamental to life in general that it was quite possible many (if not all) my symptoms and illnesses were due to my levels being so low. Obviously I needed to raise them up as quickly as possible.

I was advised to use a special skin cream and I became a victim for the second time! This time I was the victim of...

"The great Wild Yam scam"

I was advised that buying and applying a skin cream made from wild yams would get my progesterone levels up to where they should be and bring about a complete "re-balancing" of my hormones. I couldn't wait so went on the web and, after Googling a few sites (there are a seemingly endless number of "wild yam" creams out there!) I made a choice and ordered.

When my cream arrived I was very excited and applied it immediately. And the next day and the next. A week later and then a month later... no change in my symptoms.

I felt more than usually depressed.

I decided that maybe I had chosen the wrong brand so went back on the web and did more thorough research. I chose another brand of yam cream which specified "Mexican Wild Yam" (I discovered there are many varieties of yam but the only right one is "Mexican"). I allowed myself to get excited again.

Two months later and nearly $300 out of pocket my symptoms remained as bad as ever. I felt deeply disheartened. Worse still I felt foolish.

I was on the verge of accepting a life of misery when I decided that I at least owed it to myself to find out why the yam creams had not worked for me.

I worked hard, mostly researching on the web. I won't bore you with the details. Just the results. They were very simple...

Wild yams do not contain progesterone!

Now I was angry because I'd been scammed. I looked further and discovered that the manufacturers themselves didn't fully understand what they were doing. It turns out that wild yams contain a substance called diosgenin. This can be turned into progesterone in a laboratory. But...

The human body cannot turn diosgenin into progesterone!

It is impossible for wild yam creams to increase progesterone levels.

Now over 4 months and almost $300 later I had learnt a big lesson.

Now for victim number 3...

I retained my belief that a lack of progesterone could still be the cause of my problems. I looked for further medical advice. The good doctors prescribed "progesterone" pills. I took them. They didn't work. I developed other symptoms... water retention, more depression, breast cysts. I tried other "progesterone pills". Same result.

I then discovered that progesterone is destroyed in the gut! Pills therefor can't work.

More months, more money, more frustration and disappointment.

I persevered and researched more. What I learnt may astonish you as much as it did me. Here it is...

Many medical practitioners don't know the difference between "progesterone" (as its made by your body) and "progestins" or "progestogens" (as is made under patent by big pharmaceutical corporations).

This is incredible but true. I'm not the only one who's been mislead by this ignorance. Tens, perhaps hundreds of thousands have! You may ask "why don't the big pharmaceutical companies just produce progesterone as the body makes it?" The answer is shocking...

Without the patent they can't make the massive profits they are used to. They can't patent a natural substance.

A jury recently awarded a Philadelphia woman $1.5 million for breast cancer caused by a popular "hormone replacement therapy" (HRT) drug. The drug maker at the center of the lawsuit - Wyeth - is in the firing line for their estrogen drug Prempro.

Here's the real problem with HRT: Products like Premarin, Provera, and Prempro aren't actually hormones at all. They're drugs. And if you take them, you're not "replacing" anything.

Ever heard of ‘pregnancy mask’ as it develops in some women during pregnancy? Its a sign that progesterone is too low. The Pill and HRT can also cause it. Why? Because the synthetic "progestin" found in these products causes the natural progesterone level in our bodies to actually drop!

It's not surprising these drugs lead to cancer. They're not natural substances and they've never been in your body. The safe answer for menopausal symptoms is bio-identical hormone replacement. These hormones are the real thing - not drugs trying to mimic what your body produces.

Real hormones can be powerful anti-aging tools. But real hormones cannot be patented and therefore have no profit potential for the big drug makers. So companies like Wyeth make synthetic estrogen look-alikes - often with disastrous results.

I'm so upset by this that I've undertaken to write this message. Why am I so upset? Because I finally found the truth! Here it is and its dead simple...

"Natural" progesterone.

I put "natural" in quotes because it really is unnecessary to say its natural if it is truly "progesterone" and not some fake "yam" cream or artificial "progestin".

Progesterone is simply progesterone. It can't be anything else.

Now, here comes the crucial part...

How do you find it? Well I did, and in case you're wondering... I'm now well! Very well! Angry but well!

Here's what I did...

I went back on the web and researched "natural progesterone". The key word being "natural". Even then I was led up many blind alleys (you can't believe the number of scams and just plain ignorant people are out there - I was one!). The result was that I found many products that said they contained "natural" progesterone.

I researched them all. I bought and tried many.

The result? I'm happy to tell you I'm well! Well! My progesterone levels are now where they should be and my life is on track. I'm no longer tired and depressed, I've lost weight (I'd still like to lose more!), my libido is back, my skin is wonderful... you get the picture. And that's all in a few months.

It may seem amazing that so many seemingly unconnected symptoms and health problems vanished one after the other. But when you think about it for more than a moment it starts to make sense... when your body is out of balance many things go wrong.

Get it back in balance and things come right again. Progesterone is so at the root of the bodies' balance it refuses to be ignored.

There are many good products out there, as I discovered. However, my research covered a lot of ground before I became confident of results. I researched and researched.

I now want to offer you the results of my efforts so you don't have to go through what I did.

Read and then act on what follows and you can be confident you won't be scammed and you'll save months of agony and heaps of money.

What follows is a complete review of my research into "natural progesterone creams". I offer it to you so you can avoid the horrors I've been through.

If you have a progesterone deficiency then you should read on. If you don't know whether you have a progesterone deficiency you should still read on. Why? Because the quickest, lowest cost and safest way to find out is to try it for a month or two. You see the results for yourself.

Here's my complete review of real "natural" progesterone creams...

But first... what makes a good progesterone cream? Because of the horrors of my own illnesses and the complete relief I have found by using (real) progesterone cream my research has been quite exhaustive.

What criteria do I use to assess these? Here they are, just four, simple but good...

1. What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?

This is important for the following reason... A study published in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology (June 1999, pages 1504–1511) states that "In order to obtain the proper (effective) serum levels with use of a progesterone cream, the cream needs to have an adequate amount of progesterone in it [at least 30 milligrams per gram or 3%]. Many over the counter creams have little [for example, 5 milligrams per ounce] or none at all. (Note that there are 28.35 grams to an oz).

2. How effective are the carrier oils used?

Progesterone is "carried" in oil through the skin. Some oils work better than others. This is important because if you use a cream with "X" amount of progesterone in it but the carrier oil is not effective (or, horrors, a mineral oil) you may be getting only half (or less) of what you paid for! I don't want to get too technical but it is well established that the "monounsaturated" oils are the best carriers. Olive and macadamia oils are examples.

3. How organic are the ingredients?

Apart from the obvious reason that "organic is best" there is a more specific reason why this is important... Many inorganic ingredients used in creams can inhibit the absorption of progesterone. This is especially the case with emulsifying agents and preservatives a few of which are actually potentially harmful. I have relied heavily on research made available by the Environmental Working Group (EWG). EWG is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization, founded in 1993 by Ken Cook and Richard Wiles whose mission is to use the power of public information to protect public health and the environment. They provide results from the most comprehensive research of all cosmetic ingredients on the planet! If you want to learn more about the EWG rating system I use below then please visit their website at the link above (it opens a new window so you won't lose me!)

4. What is the cost?

Needless to say in matters of health cost is not everything. However, if all other things are equal why pay more? There is one vitally important point about the cost of progesterone creams that is nearly always overlooked. I only became aware of it after I'd bought 5 or 6 different creams. It is this... make sure you are paying for the progesterone contained in the cream and not for the cream itself. This may sound a bit confusing so let me give an example. Cream "A" comes in a tube containing 2oz of cream. Cream "B" comes in, lets say, a jar which also contains 2oz of cream. Both creams contain equally good ingredients and both sell for $30. So how do you decide? Check the progesterone content! Cream "A" contains 900mg of progesterone. Cream"B" contains 1,200mg. This means you're paying $33.33 per gram of progesterone contained in cream "A" whereas you're only paying $25 per gram for cream "B"! That's a saving of 25%! See how important it is to be extra careful to know exactly what it is you're buying. You won't believe the number of "label jobs" (just enough progesterone to justify having it on the label... like 2mg per 2oz!) are on the market.

I give a score out of 10 for each of the above. This means the potential maximum is 40 points for each product.

I've left pretty much no stone unturned in getting to the best. How many progesterone creams are there? No one knows for sure but I've researched over 60 and I know there are more. This took me several weeks.

What follows is a review of the 7 best real (read "natural") progesterone creams available. Each is assessed according to the criteria above.

I recommend all of them.

A word of caution... If you click on any of the product links (I've given them so you can see for yourself... again, they open in a new window so you won't lose me!) just don't buy anything until you've done the "progesterone deficiency" questionnaire you'll find at the end of this message.

They are presented in alphabetical order (the scorecards speak for themselves).

Here goes...

Product #1

AIM Renewed Balance

  • Ingredients: Purified Water, Stearl Konium Chloride, Vitamin E, Natural Glycerin, Avocado Oil, USP-Certified Natural Progesterone, Aloe Vera Oil, Vitamin A Palmitate, Rosemary Extract, Carrot Oil, Lemon Oil
  • Container: 1.6 oz Pump or 2 oz. Jar. 1104 mgs. progesterone per Pump. 1120 mgs. progesterone per Jar
  • Price: $25.00 ea.

Scorecard...

  • What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?
    • 24.34 milligrams per gram (based on best case - Pump) (2.43%) Score:6.5
  • How effective are the carrier oils used?
    • Avocado Oil is a good carrier but lacks the stability of some of the best carrier oils. Score:7.0
  • How organic are the ingredients?
    • Stearalkonium Chloride: EWG rating "low hazard". The preservative systm is apparently only the Rosemary extract. Most expert opinion questions whether it is reliable acting alone. Some products are known to include parabens ("moderate" hazard) to support organic preservatives without declaring them. There is no reason to suspect this of this product. Score:7.0
  • What is the cost?
    • $22.32 per gram of progesterone (based on best case - jar). Score:4.6
  • Overall score: 25.1

Product #2

Emerita Pro-Gest

  • Ingredients: Water, Tocopheryl Acetate (Vit E), Aloe Barbadensis (Aloe Vera) Leaf Juice, Carthamus Tinctorius (Hybrid Safflower) Seed Oil, Panthenol, Glycerin, Prunus Amygdalus Dulcis (Sweet Almond) Oil, Glyceryl Stearate, Cetyl Alcohol, Sodium Behenoyl Lactylate, Stearic Acid, USP Progesterone, Phenoxyethanol, Caprylyl Glycol, Sorbic Acid, Citrus Aurantium Dulcis (Orange) Oil, Citrus Medica Limonum (Lemon) Peel Oil, Carbomer
  • Container: 2 oz or 4 oz tubes (450 mg USP Progesterone per oz)
  • Price: 2 oz - $19.99 (sale price), 4 oz - $39.99

Scorecard...

  • What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?
    • 15.87 milligrams per gram (1.59%) Score:4.3
  • How effective are the carrier oils used?
    • Safflower oil is a low cost carrier. There are better alternatives. Score:5.0
  • How organic are the ingredients?
    • Sodium Behenoyl Lactylate: EWG rating "low hazard". Phenoxyethanol: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Sorbic Acid: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Score:4.5
  • What is the cost?
    • $22.21 per gram of progesterone (sale price). Score:4.7
  • Overall score: 18.5

Product #3

Natpro natural progesterone cream

  • Ingredients: spring water, organic virgin macadamia oil, Pharmaceutical grade natural progesterone 2000 mg, organic citrus extract, glyceryl stearate, vegetable glycerine, sodium borate, cetearyl alcohol, cetearyl glucoside, vitamin E, titanium dioxide, silver chloride
  • Container: 2 oz tube (60 gram) - 2,000mg USP progesterone per tube
  • Price: $69.00 per set of 3 tubes

Scorecard...

  • What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?
    • 33.33 milligrams per gram (3.33%) Score:9.0
  • How effective are the carrier oils used?
    • Macadamia oil: very close to the skin's own oil, very stable (mono-unsaturated) effective carrier. Score:8.0
  • How organic are the ingredients?
    • Sodium borate: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Titanium dioxide: EWG rating "low hazard". Silver chloride: EWG rating "low hazard". Score:5.5
  • What is the cost?
    • $11.50 per gram of progesterone. Score:9.0
  • Overall score: 31.5

Product #4

NutriVera Naturals

  • Ingredients: 2000mg Micronized Natural Progesterone USP from Wild Yam, Deionized Water, Lanol, Sepigel, Liposome Carrier System, Omega Oils, Germaben.
  • Container: 4 oz. jar
  • Price: Reg. $34.95, Sale. $28.50

Scorecard...

  • What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?
    • 17.67 milligrams per gram (1.77%) Score:4.7
  • How effective are the carrier oils used?
    • Liposome systems appear to be effective although no definitive studies have been carried out. Score:7.5
  • How organic are the ingredients?
    • Sepigel: EWG rating "low hazard". Germaben (contains: Propylene Glycol "moderate hazard"; Diazolidinyl Urea; Methylparaben "moderate hazard"; Propylparaben "moderate hazard"): EWG rating "moderate hazard". Score:6.0
  • What is the cost?
    • $14.25 per gram of progesterone (based on best case - sale price). Score:7.3
  • Overall score: 25.5

Product #5

Oasis Serene

  • Ingredients: "Wellness" Water, Vegetable Stearic Acid, Sweet Almond Oil, Vegetable Glycerine, Cold-Pressed–Whole Leaf Aloe Vera, USP Progesterone (Mexican Wild Yam), Vitamins A (emulsified), Living B-Complex, C (Camu Camu), D-3 (emulsified) & E (mixed tocopherols and tocotrienols) and Rosemary Essential Oil (Rosmarinus officinalis).
  • Container: 2 oz jar 750 mg of USP progesterone per ounce.
  • Price: best offer - 3 for $24.99 each 1,500 mg of USP progesterone per ounce.

Scorecard...

  • What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?
    • 26.45 milligrams per gram (based on best case - 1,500mg) (2.65%) Score:7.1
  • How effective are the carrier oils used?
    • Sweet almond oil is a high value and effective (mono-unsaturated) carrier oil. Score:8.0
  • How organic are the ingredients?
    • Stearic Acid: EWG rating "low to moderate hazard". The preservative systm is apparently only the rosemary oil. Most expert opinion questions whether it is reliable acting alone. Some products are known to include parabens ("moderate" hazard) to support organic preservatives without declaring them. There is no reason to suspect this of this product. Score:6.5
  • What is the cost?
    • $14.66 per gram of progesterone (based on best case - 1,500mg/oz). Score:7.1
  • Overall score: 28.7

Product #6

Progesta-Care

  • Ingredients:  Purified & Deionized Water, Aloe Vera Gel, Caprylic/Capric Triglycerides, Shea Butter, Sunflower Seed Oil, Stearic Acid, Natural Progesterone USP (Micronized), Vegetable Glycerin, Glyceryl Stearate, Phenoxyethanol Caprylyl Glycol, Sterol Alcohol, Isopropyl Palmitate, MSM (Methylsulfonylmethane), Evening Primose (Oenothera Biennis) Oil, Lecithin, Tocotrienols (Natural Super Vitamin E), Sodium Hyaluronate, Sodium Bicarbonate, Burdock Root, Allantoin, Carbomer, Disodium EDTA, Potassium Sorbate, Grape Seed Extract.
  • Container: 4 oz. Pump Container. Each ounce contains:  480 mg (20 mg per pump) of Natural USP Progesterone
  • Price: $26.00 - Discount Price offered at time of research (Reg price: $34.95)

Scorecard...

  • What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?
    • 16.93 milligrams per gram (1.69%) Score:4.6
  • How effective are the carrier oils used?
    • Sunflower Seed Oil is a low cost carrier. There are better alternatives. Score:5.0
  • How organic are the ingredients?
    • Phenoxyethanol: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Disodium EDTA: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Isopropyl Palmitate: EWG rating "low hazard" Score:4.5
  • What is the cost?
    • $13.54 per gram of progesterone. Score:7.6
  • Overall score: 21.7

Product #7

Serenity

  • Ingredients: Deionised Water, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, Vegetable Oil, Glycerin, USP Natural Progesterone (2.34%) USA, Isopropyl Myristate, Glyceryl Stearate SE, Cetyl Alcohol, PEG-20 Methyl Glucose Sesquistearate, Stearic Acid, Sodium Hyaluronate, Sodium PCA, d alpha Tocopherol, Methyl Glucose Sesquistearate, Grapefruit Seed Extract, Xanthan Gum, Carbomer, Aminomethyl Propanol, Diazolidinyl Urea, Methylparaben, Propylparaben
  • Container: 2.1ozs (60gm/60ml) jar (1,260 mgs of USP Pharmaceutical grade Natural Progesterone)
  • Price:  £17.99 (@ $2 to £1 = $35.98)

Scorecard...

  • What quantity of progesterone is contained per weight of cream?
    • 21.00 milligrams per gram (2.1%) Score:5.6
  • How effective are the carrier oils used?
    • "Vegetable oil" could be anything. Because its unspecified its likely to be a low cost oil without the better carrier qualities of other oils. Score:4.5
  • How organic are the ingredients?
    • PEG-20 Methyl Glucose Sesquistearate: EWG rating "low hazard" (note, however, that all PEG’s potentially contain the powerful carcinogen dioxane). Aminomethyl Propanol: EWG rating "low to moderate hazard". Diazolidinyl Urea: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Methylparaben: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Propylparaben: EWG rating "moderate hazard". Score:3.5
  • What is the cost?
    • $28.55 per gram of progesterone. Score:3.6
  • Overall score: 17.2

So there you have it. Here's the overall ranking...

  1. Natpro 31.5
  2. Oasis Serene 28.7
  3. NutriVera Naturals 25.5
  4. AIM Renewed Balance 25.1
  5. Progesta-Care 21.7
  6. Emerita Pro-Gest 18.5
  7. Serenity 17.2

Which one do I use?

Well, as I said before, I've used them all. They are all good (that's why they made it through to the "final 7"!). However, Natpro is my first choice. The others are good so don't let me dissuade you from trying them but in my opinion Natpro is not only at least as good a product as any other it provides far and away the best value... just look at the "cost per gram" scores again.

Now, here's how to answer the all important question...

"Do You have a progesterone deficiency?

Do this questionnaire and find out right away. Its free and only takes 10 minutes.


Just enter your email address and click the button...

Why do I ask for your email address? Simply to stay in touch to see how you are doing and keep you updated. Your details will not be revealed to anyone for any reason.

To your very best health,

Jane Miller
Wilmington DE


Disclaimer:

This web site is not intended to be prescriptive. You are advised to seek medical advice and refer any health problem to a health care practitioner.


This web site copyright ©2008 progesterone-research.com. All rights reserved.